You are here

The time spent caring for family is not only ignored - it actually hurts your retirement

John Church
Written by: John Church


Yesterday’s budget did very little for tens of thousands of pensioners losing as much as €1,500 a year for taking time out of the workforce to care for their families. They won’t even get the five euro they read about in yesterday’s paper.

Orla O’Connor of the National Women’s Council, Marie O’Toole of the Irish Countywomen’s Association and Lorraine Fitzsimons of Age Action urging support for our petition for a fair State Pension.

This is because the previous Government changed the eligibility criteria for the Contributory State Pension in 2012. While those entitled to a full pension were unaffected, those who would have been in line for smaller pensions lost out.

Not everyone gets the full State Pension because not everyone has a full record of PRSI contributions. Many pensioners, mostly women, left the workforce to care for their families. Others were forced out by the marriage bar.

They’re still entitled to a pension, but a smaller one, and in 2012 it was made smaller again.

Under the old system, if you had an average of 20 contributions, for example, you would have been entitled to €228.70. But after 2012, this dropped to €198.60, a cut of more of more than thirty euro each week.

Mean and sneaky

As one of our members put it, this was a ‘mean and sneaky cut’. It cut the pensions of those who would have been getting smaller pensions anyway and it has helped to widen an already large gender pension gap in Ireland.

The situation is made worse by the ‘averaging rule’ used to calculate your pension.

The number of PRSI contributions a worker makes is divided by the number of years between her first day of work and her retirement.

For example, take someone who worked for a few months in 1968 and then left to raise a family. During her time away from work she would not have made any PRSI contributions. She goes back to work in 2000 and retires in 2016.

Her total number of contributions are divided by 48, from when she started work in 1968, and as a result she gets a much smaller pension. Her time caring for her family is not only ignored, it actually reduces her pension.

If she had not gone to work in 1968 she would have been entitled to a full State Pension. People are being punished because they went to work in the 60s and 70s.

And because the five euro is only for people on the top rate of the State Pension, these pensioners only get a portion of that increase so they lose out every single year. 

5,000 voices ignored

We need a fair pension system in Ireland that values the contributions made by our carers – men and women. The Homemaker’s Scheme, introduced in 1994, needs to be backdated so that those who provided care before then can benefit. We must introduce measures that addresses the gender pension gap.

We know all of that cannot be done in a single budget. We know that will take time. But we also know the changes brought in five years ago could have been reversed yesterday.

Last week Age Action delivered 5,000 signatures to Minister Regina Doherty collected by our members and by our colleagues in the Irish Countrywomen’s Association and the National Women’s Council of Ireland.

Each one of these signatures was a voice raised on behalf of these pensioners.

Each of them was calling for a fair State Pension system, one that does not punish those whose contribution to our society was raising a family or caring for a loved one.

Each asked for the changes introduced in 2012 to be reversed.

Yesterday, every single one of them was ignored, so we’re asking Minister Donohoe again to give these pensioners a fair deal and to reverse a mean and sneaky cut. 



I would like to add my name to the list of signatures. It is unfair and discriminatory that our pensions are not equitable just because we stayed home to rear our children. Keep up the fight for equality.

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

New store opens in Galway

Age Action Deputy Chief Executive Lorraine Fitzsimons holds the ribbon for customer June Smyth

Age Action's sixth charity store has officially opened at 3 St Francis Street in the heart of Galway City. Bargain-hunters would be well advised to drop in soon to check out the store's fantastic selection of clothes, bags, jewellery, and vintage accessories.